fbpx
Product vs. Product art have distinct outcomes depending on what your goals are for your child engaging in art.

What is the Difference Between Process Art vs. Product Art?

Dive into the creative world of early childhood art with a clear explanation of process versus product art. This post breaks down the benefits and considerations of each approach, empowering parents to nurture their child's artistic journey with intention.

Table of Contents

Both process art and product art have their own unique benefits and challenges in fostering creativity, critical thinking, and skill development.
Both process art and product art have their own unique benefits and challenges in fostering creativity, critical thinking, and skill development.

In my journey with TigerKubz, I’ve discovered the intriguing world of process versus product art in early childhood education, a concept that’s both exciting and sometimes overwhelming. This post aims to shed light on the differences between these two approaches: process art, which emphasizes the creative journey and allows children the freedom to explore and express with no specific outcome in mind, and product art, which focuses on crafting a finished piece that meets certain criteria.

Each has its unique benefits and challenges in fostering creativity, critical thinking, and skill development in young minds. As we delve into the pros and cons of process and product art, we’ll see how they contribute to a child’s artistic and personal growth.

Understanding the Distinction Between Process Art and Product Art

Girl building with Lego; building according to kit instructions exemplifies product art, while spontaneous construction embodies process art.
Building with Lego according to kit instructions exemplifies product art, while spontaneous construction embodies process art.

A simple yet effective way to grasp the difference between process art and product art is by thinking about how we interact with a Lego set. Imagine purchasing a Lego kit; the goal for you or your child often becomes to replicate the detailed design pictured on the box. This approach, where the aim is to produce a specific outcome that matches the model, epitomizes product art. The focus here is squarely on the end result, ensuring that the final creation mirrors the expected product.

Now, imagine using the same Lego bricks without a guidebook or intended design. You start building spontaneously, fueled by curiosity and the thrill of discovery, unconcerned with the final outcome. This is the essence of process art: valuing the creative journey more than the destination, much like a ‘Masterbuilder’ from the Lego Movie, where imagination and experimentation know no bounds.

This Lego analogy highlights the core difference between process art and product art. One prioritizes the experience and exploration of creating, while the other focuses on achieving a predetermined visual outcome. Both forms of art play important roles in development and learning, offering unique benefits and insights into the creative process.

Moving Beyond Pinterest-Perfect Projects

Woman sitting on sofa looking on her ipad on the Pinterest app looking for art projects that are mainly product art focused instead of process art.
Most searches conducted online and on Pinterest are typically product art focused with a specific end result in mind.

When we dive into the world of online arts and crafts, especially on platforms like Pinterest, what we often find falls into the realm of product art. You know those “Pinterest-worthy” projects, right? Our searches—filled with terms like “apple crafts for preschoolers,” “cute pumpkin themed crafts,” or “Valentine’s Day crafts”—lead us predominantly towards outcomes that are visually appealing and meticulously crafted. These searches shape our expectations, nudging us towards aiming for a specific look or outcome.

For many parents, especially those of us not formally trained in education, the focus naturally gravitates toward the end product. It’s a reflection, perhaps, of a broader cultural and workplace emphasis on outcomes over processes. But here’s a thought: what if introducing art to young children was about more than just replicating the most adorable craft seen online? What if it was simpler, and maybe even more enriching, than that?

Exploring Process Art in Early Childhood

Child exploring a paint palette while holding a paintbrush and embracing process art.
Process art is the exploration of creativity, offering children a set of tools and the freedom to express themselves without the constraints of specific outcomes.

As we navigate away from the ‘Pinterest-perfect’ expectations, let’s explore process art. Process art in the early years is the exploration of creativity, offering children a set of tools and the freedom to express themselves without the constraints of specific outcomes. This approach is about setting simple guidelines and boundaries for tool usage, while empowering children with the autonomy to let their imaginations lead the way. Boundaries can look like, “paint is for paper, not for walls” and “smocks keep our clothes clean while we paint”.

Early creations might not seem gallery-ready to those unfamiliar with the philosophy behind process art. Toddlers are still mastering their motor skills and don’t have the same ability to control art materials precisely as older children or adults. But, is the goal of art in these formative years really precision and control? Of course not. Our aim is to celebrate their journey into creative expression, even if that means our fridges become galleries of abstract masterpieces.

Understanding the developmental stages of art in toddlers and preschoolers enriches our appreciation of their creative process. That “scribble” isn’t merely random marks on a page; it’s a critical developmental step towards intentional shape formation and, eventually, recognizable drawings. These are the building blocks of visual and spatial understanding, worthy of every bit of admiration.

Consider the child who mixes paints, not to make a mess, but to discover what happens when colors blend. They’re conducting their first experiments with color theory. They learned firsthand that combining all the colors produces black—a surprising discovery that adds a new dimension to their palette. This discovery highlights the importance of exploration in art and prompts us to reflect on our deeper objectives for our children’s creative journeys. As we peel back the layers of these experiences, we are going to explore the purpose behind the art we choose for our children so we can guide them through a world where creativity meets intention.

Understanding the Purpose Behind Art for Your Child

Clarifying your objectives for art projects guides the choice between process and product art styles.
Clarifying your objectives for art projects guides the choice between process and product art styles.

Understanding your intentions is the first step in choosing the type of art your child engages in. Whether you’re aiming to create tangible keepsakes for grandma’s Mother’s Day present or cultivate your child’s creative spirit, it’s essential to recognize how both process and product art can play pivotal roles in achieving these objectives.

A Balanced Approach to Artistic Development:

  1. Keepsakes and Gifts: Product art often comes to mind with its structured approach to creating mementos. Yet, process art can also yield unexpected treasures that carry deep personal meaning.
  2. Creative Development: While process art is renowned for fostering creativity and independence, product art can introduce new techniques and structured creativity, offering a different kind of innovative challenge.
  3. Educational Enhancement: Art bridges learning concepts across subjects. Product art provides tangible projects linked to academic themes, whereas process art offers a more explorative connection, enriching the learning experience through discovery.
  4. Emotional Expression and Regulation: The freedom of process art offers a therapeutic outlet for children’s emotions, complemented by the structured expression within product art that can also provide emotional relief and a sense of achievement.
  5. Social Skills Development: Both art forms encourage social interaction, whether through collaborative projects in product art or shared exploratory sessions in process art.
  6. Cultivating Problem-Solving Skills: The decision-making and critical thinking fostered by process art’s open-ended exploration are equally matched by the focused problem-solving required in product art projects.
  7. Enhancing Fine Motor Skills: Process art allows children to experiment with movements and materials freely, while product art refines these skills through precise tasks.
ObjectiveProcess ArtProduct Art
Keepsakes and Gifts– Encourages exploration with personal meaning.
– Might result in unique, albeit unexpected, gifts.
Examples: Handprint art, freeform clay sculptures.
– Provides a structured approach for creating specific items.
– Offers pride in meeting aesthetic goals.
Examples: Themed holiday cards, crafted jewelry.
Creative Development– Fosters creativity, independence, and innovation through unstructured exploration.
Examples: Splatter painting, mixed media collage with various materials.
– Can introduce new techniques within a structured framework, guiding creativity towards a specific outcome.
Examples: Following a painting tutorial, origami.
Educational Enhancement– Encourages connections between art and academic concepts in an exploratory manner.
Examples: Color mixing experiments, nature-based sensory bins.
– Structured projects can directly reinforce learning in math, science, and literacy.
Examples: Counting bead necklaces, alphabet stamps.
Emotional Expression and Regulation– Offers a therapeutic outlet for free expression of emotions.
– Helps in developing emotional intelligence.
Examples: Free drawing, playdough sculpting.
– May provide a sense of relief and achievement through the completion of a structured task.
Examples: Mandala coloring, emotion-themed storyboards.
Social Skills Development– Promotes sharing and appreciation of diverse perspectives in a group setting.
Examples: Group mural painting, shared craft stations.
– Requires collaboration and teamwork to achieve a common goal, enhancing social interactions.
Examples: Collaborative mosaic, group-built model kits.
Problem-Solving Skills– Encourages critical thinking and decision-making in an open-ended environment.
Examples: Building with recyclables, creating art from found objects.
– Presents specific challenges to solve, refining critical thinking within set parameters.
Examples: Puzzle assembly art, kit-based model painting.
Fine Motor Skills– Allows for the development of motor skills through varied, unrestricted movements.
Examples: Finger painting, threading beads on strings.
– Focuses on refining fine motor skills through detailed, precise tasks.
Examples: Cutting shapes for collages, detailed coloring books.
Balancing Process and Product Art: Objectives and Examples for Engaging Children in Artistic Exploration and Creation

Reflecting on what you value most in your child’s art activities will help determine the balance between process and product art. Whether it’s the shared and displayed final product or the creative exploration along the way, each serves a purpose in supporting your child’s development.

A balanced art education, incorporating elements of both approaches, ensures children experience the joys of creating freely and the satisfaction of completing specific projects. This holistic approach to art nurtures their creativity, skills, and personal growth in a diverse and enriching manner.

Pros and Cons of Product Art vs. Process Art

Early childhood educators we’re taught never to alter a child’s artwork. This principle honors the integrity of a child’s creative process and decisions, irrespective of whether the outcome aligns with our preconceived “expectations.” Reflecting on my own journey, I confess to moments of overstepping — directing where an eye should go, suggesting a flower over an abstract stroke, or insisting a house isn’t complete without a door. My interventions, aimed at perfection, often missed the mark of fostering true creativity. Yikes, indeed.

However, I’ve learned to extend grace to myself with time and increased awareness. My journey has taught me the value of both process and product in art, and I’m eager to share these insights with you. If your approach has leaned heavily towards product-based art, there’s no need for concern. Introducing your child to product-based art does come with its unique set of advantages.

ProsCons
Process Art– Encourages creativity and freewill
– Promotes experimentation and self-direction
– Boosts self-esteem
– Results in original work
– Always developmentally appropriate
– Values the journey, leading to cognitive flexibility
– May be misunderstood by caregivers
– Might not satisfy children struggling with creativity or fine motor skills
– Can lack project closure
– Requires tolerance for mess
Product Art– Introduces new art processes
– Practices following instructions
– Reinforces subject learning through themed artwork
– Provides structure and guidance
– Boosts confidence with model replication
– Creates shareable, tangible products
– Limits originality
– Restricts creativity
– Some projects may not be developmentally appropriate, leading to frustration
– Focus on outcomes can suppress creativity
– May discourage risk-taking
– Potentially stifles creative exploration with “right/wrong” creation concepts
Pros and Cons of Engaging in Process Art vs. Product Art

Integration with Broader Learning Concepts

While exploring the difference between process and product art, it’s essential to consider how these concepts fit into broader learning activities at home. For those curious about integrating art into a comprehensive early education framework, our post ‘Ultimate Guide to At-Home Learning Activities for Toddlers‘ offers a wealth of ideas, seamlessly blending artistic creativity with subjects like literacy and math.

Connection to Literacy-Based Learning

Artistic expression, whether through process or product art, paves the way for deeper learning experiences. Literacy-based curriculums like Five in a Row (FIAR) is further enriched by the practical hands-on resources offered by TigerKubz preschool learning activity kits.

Both FIAR and TigerKubz leverage the magic of storytelling across a broad spectrum of subjects, beautifully marrying art with literature to foster a comprehensive educational experience. This approach not only nurtures a love for reading but also exposes children to a diversity of art styles, enhancing their visual literacy and appreciation for creativity.

Dive into our exploration of how FIAR’s literacy-based approach, coupled with the versatility of TigerKubz learning kits, can intertwine to significantly enrich your child’s education, broadening their understanding and appreciation of art in its many forms.

So, which is better? Product or process art?

B is for The Runaway Bunny Free Alphabet Letter Craft
Caregivers can teach letter recognition with product art crafts such as “B is for Bunny” | via Tigerkubz: The Runaway Bunny Learning Kit

Faced with the choice between product and process art, which prevails? As we’ve explored, each approach has unique advantages and challenges. Embracing the philosophy that “moderation is key,” I find this concept also applies perfectly to art education. While product art has been a staple in our activities, offering my children the joy of creating with a goal in sight, we’ve equally embraced the freedom and discovery that comes with process art.

Our experiences with product-based projects, especially through literacy-based lessons like those in the TigerKubz learning kits, demonstrate the tangible benefits of product art. Activities such as “B is for Bunny” or exploring art techniques inspired by “Brown Bear, Brown Bear” leverage familiar characters to enhance letter recognition and artistic skills, providing a structured pathway to learning that complements the exploratory nature of process art.

Ultimately, framing the debate as a choice between process art or product art misses the mark. The real value lies in recognizing the contributions of both to a child’s development. My hope is that by sharing the insights gained from both approaches, this post empowers you to craft an art experience for your child that is as diverse and enriching as their imagination allows. So, rather than asking “which is better?” perhaps the question should be “how can we integrate the best of both worlds?”

Table of Contents

Share:

Practical Tips to Empower Little Learners

Delivered straight to your Inbox

Empowerment Base

TigerKubz Preschool Storybook-based Learning Kits

How it Works

Read

Transform storytime into a springboard for discovery. Discuss the story with your child to uncover their interests and learning needs.

Play

Dive into play-based learning with activities from our learning kits that relate to your child’s favorite stories. Foster a deeper connection and understanding through fun!

Connect

Watch as your child’s comprehension grows with every story. Our learning kit activities deepen their insight, making each reread a new adventure.

Subscribe to TigerKubz's newsletter for printables, early childhood education tips, giveaways, and new product updates

Don’t miss out on learning opportunities!

Get the newest posts, free printables, and giveaways sent directly to your email

We're Social! Connect with Us.

Join Waitlist We will inform you when the product arrives in stock. Please leave your valid email address below.

No fields found, please go to settings & save/reset fields

Hey Super Parent! Before You Go...

Dive Deeper into the World of Early Childhood Education

From understanding the science behind color recognition to crafting the perfect learning kit for your little explorer, TigerKubz’s Empowerment Base is your go-to resource. Don’t miss out on our exclusive articles, insights, and activities tailored for parents like you.